
Prokofiev
The Love for Three Oranges Op. 33a, excerpts
Shostakovich
Symphony No. 6 in B minor, Op. 54
Mussorgsky/Stokowski
Symphonic Synthesis – Boris Godunov
Tchaikovsky
The Tempest, Op. 18
Tchaikovsky
The Storm, Op. 76
Prokofiev
Alexander Nevsky, Cantata, Op. 78
Mussorgsky
Pictures from an Exhibition (orchestrated Stokowski)
Jennie Tourel (mezzo-soprano)
Westminster Choir
NBC Symphony Orchestra
Leopold Stokowski
Recorded between November 1941 and March 1943 at Cosmopolitan Opera House, New York and at NBC Studio 8-H, Radio City, New York
Reviewed by: Gregor Tassie
Reviewed: October 2026
CD No: Pristine Classical: CD, downloads and stream: PASC 777
Duration: Duration: 153.49
Stokowski was among a small group of conductors who were enthusiastically drawn to Russian music, particularly the new school of 20th-century composers, including the then little-known Shostakovich. On his first visit to the Soviet Union in 1935, Stokowski met the leading composers in Moscow, Kiev and Leningrad. He met with Amirov, Glière, Kabalevsky, Myaskovsky, Khrennikov, Khachaturyan, Prokofiev, and Shostakovich. It was Stokowski who first introduced the music of Shostakovich to American audiences, most notably premiering the Fifth Symphony in Philadelphia. All of these composers’ music was performed and recorded in Philadelphia and New York, including with the NBC Symphony Orchestra. Stokowski’s recordings of Shostakovich’s Fifth and Seventh symphonies are outstanding historical documents.
It may have been that his Slavic roots gave him the gift to both sense and feel the music, and this certainly proved crucial in his arrangements of works by Mussorgsky and others. Stokowski’s collaborations with Rachmaninov were highlights in 20th-century recordings, premiering the Third Symphony and the Fourth Piano Concerto (with the composer). However, his arrangements of Bach and other Baroque composers, despite being highly popular, became unfashionable after the rise of the ‘early music’ movement, and his arrangements for a time lost their popularity.
Nevertheless, here in this collection, Stokowski’s gift for finding the emotional core of the music is manifest. Stokowski established a reputation with the Philadelphia Orchestra; however, these recordings with the NBC Symphony Orchestra show his work at its very best in establishing an important artistic relationship during the war years. Significantly, Stokowski prepared the NBC Symphony for Toscanini, ensuring that the ensemble would be on the highest level of virtuosity and with a true orchestral unity.
These recordings are from both public concerts and studio recordings, and one can sense the atmosphere, especially in those recorded in the Cosmopolitan Opera House in New York, and the warm applause for the Shostakovich Sixth at the NBC Studio in 1942, when both countries were in a wartime alliance. Stokowski takes a firm approach in the opening ‘Infernal Scene’ from Prokofiev’s suite from Love for Three Oranges, adopting a dreamy and mysterious mood on the strings and horns, before machine-like motoric modernisms, like trains in the night, thumps and shrieks against the screams of the wind and percussion. In the ‘Prince and the Princess’, we hear a lament on the strings, accompanied by a tentative mood, before a sudden shriek from the woodwind and a violin solo that invokes a feeling of heartbreak, enhanced by the harp and oboe. The famous ‘March’ has an electrifying clarity and gives the sense of hearing it for the first time, with tremendous playing from Stokowski’s musicians, often playing with a swagger; unsurprising, there is applause at the end.
Stokowski gave the US premiere of the Shostakovich Sixth with the Philadelphia Orchestra in 1940, less than a year after its world premiere in Leningrad, and here in New York, he directed a quite remarkable performance. So impressed was I by this recording that I immediately listened to it a second time; it was so enjoyable to hear the magnificent virtuosity, from the first violin solo, the flute solos, and the wonderful trumpet playing, matched by outstanding playing from the strings. At all times, Stokowski maintains a gripping hold on the tempo, bringing out all the magnificence of the score. The Shostakovich Sixth is one of the highlights of this issue, with the remarkable opening Largo, followed by an exciting Allegro and the moving, brightly coloured Presto finale. The audience expressed its appreciation for the music by applauding after each of the three movements.
Stokowski selected six scenes for the Symphonic Synthesis from Boris Godunov. In the opening, ‘Outside the Novodevichy Monastery’, we hear an old folk song on the strings, and there emerges a darkly dramatic passage on the violins; in the highly dramatic scene of ‘The Coronation of Boris’, the mood is enhanced excitingly by the brass, with the thrillingly tolling bells. In ‘The Monks chanting in the Chudov Monastery’, the atmosphere is gripping, with bells tolling and a deeply sad passage from the strings portraying the sonority of monks singing, accompanied by a harp, enhancing the mourning of Russia. ‘The Siege of Kazan’ sharply changes the mood with brass and woodwind erupting in dramatic excitement, sounding like a train building tension and bringing out all the drama of the narrative. ‘Outside the Church of St Basil’ reprises the deep sadness of before with atmospheric strings; a Russian folk song is quoted on the strings, with the brass predicting a terrible fate for Russia. In the closing ‘The Death of Boris’, again the brass announces the motto of Boris, with the mourning and the percussion tolling in a thrilling closure. One feels like joining in the enthusiastic applause afterwards.
In Tchaikovsky’s The Tempest, there is a great build-up of tension, reminding me somewhat of Golovanov in his orchestral direction (Golovanov was famous for his rearrangements of orchestration at the Bolshoi Theatre). Stokowski accentuates all the rich harmonies of Tchaikovsky’s score, all clearly heard. Here the conductor secures the sumptuous sound qualities that were so characteristic of his Philadelphia Orchestra. In The Storm, a piece he rarely performed, there is a tense, dark, mysterious drama with quite excellent sound, and it is difficult to believe this is from more than eighty years ago.
In the second Prokofiev recording here, the opening of the Alexander Nevsky Cantata, ‘Under the Mongol Yoke’, is superbly atmospheric and, at moments, spine-chilling from the exquisitely virtuosic strings. In ‘The Song of Nevsky’, the choral singing is excellent and emotional, although singing in English, the sound and the sonority do not match the Russian texts in the score. However, ‘The Crusaders in Pskov’ is spectacular, with exceptional, quite terrifying brass playing, enhancing the dramatic tension, and the degree of emotion is supplemented by the excellent women’s chorus. In the gripping scene of the ‘Battle on the Ice’, there is great suspense in the strings and brass, yet here the singing lacks that unique Russian feeling. The drowning scene of the Teutonic Knights is colourful in its stunning imagery from the strings and harps heralding the mood of victory with the mixed chorus. The thrilling atmosphere continues in the ‘Field of the Dead’, with magnificent singing evincing the grief of the losses in wartime. ‘Alexander’s Entry into Pskov’ brings the cantata to a spectacular close with breathtaking orchestral playing, backed by joyous triumph from the fervent singing of the Westminster Choir, accompanied by bells in a celebratory ending. The mezzo-soprano, Jenny Tourel, despite her Russian ethnicity, sings in English, magnificently, bringing all the horror of the war in her lament.
In Stokowski’s arrangement for Mussorgsky’s Pictures from an Exhibition, Stokowski brings out all the genius of the Russian composer’s creation through his rich, colourful orchestration; some aspects are perhaps questionable in comparison to those versions by Rimsky Korsakov and Ravel; this is especially noticeable in the brass, but exciting modifications create a unique version, especially in the Great Gate of Kiev in the finale. The ‘Gnomus’ was both exciting and dramatic, and ‘The Old Castle’ was particularly colourful with lovely virtuosity from the solo bassoon. There was plenty of nobility in ‘Bydlo’ and ‘The Ballet of the Unhatched Chicks’ was brilliant, with the lovely woodwind orchestration and a virtuoso piccolo; Stokowski gives ‘Cum mortuis in lingua mortua’ a sense of fantasy brought to life with pictures more real than in Ravel’s orchestration. The element of colour is evident in the magical, exciting scene of ‘The Hut of Fowl’s Legs’, and there was plenty of grandeur from the percussion and brass’ spectacular triumphant chords in ‘The Great Gate of Kiev’. Stokowski omitted ‘The Tuileries’ and ‘The Marketplace at Limoges’ from his arrangement perhaps for maintaining the Russianness of the score.
In all, this is a must-buy for those who love Russian music; despite having most of these recordings by other conductors, the quality of the playing is matched by the remarkable remastering by Pristine Audio where the mono images have been broadened. Stokowski conducted other Russian composers who have become rarely heard now, and perhaps a second release of Stokowski’s recordings of Glière, Kabalevsky, Myaskovsky and more Prokofiev and Shostakovich could make a great second album.
Please note the album is only available direct from Pristine Classical.
