The central Mahler Symphonies in uninspiring performances from Nelsons and the VPO

andris nelsons mahler symphonies nos 5 7
3 of 5 stars

Mahler
Symphony No. 5 in C sharp minor
Symphony No. 6 in A minor
Symphony No. 7 in E minor

Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra
Andris Nelsons

Recorded live at the Grosses Festspielhaus, Salzburg in August 2022 and August 2020 and at the Musikverein, Vienna in January 2023 

 


Reviewed by: David Gutman

Reviewed: November 2026
CD No: Catalogue No: DG download and stream: DG 4869428 [also part of a 12-CD complete box set]
Duration: Duration: 4 hours 6 minutes

As we come to the core of Gustav Mahler’s symphony cycle, his reliance on song-derived melody gives way to a sharper focus on structure and form. Some recent performances have pursued a strategy in which high seriousness is sacrificed to a brand of technically pristine music-making that risks turning these works into a sequence of concerti for orchestra. Not so with Andris Nelsons, for whom they are unmistakably big, heavyweight symphonic statements.

Deutsche Grammophon has released his complete cycle as a 12CD set, which can also be downloaded in three parts, with booklets, of which this is the middle one. That said, the yellow label’s curious marketing strategy means that not all these renditions are entirely new. The Fifth has been downloadable for some time—a deliberate ‘taster’ that is also obtainable on two LPs. That seems an odd choice given that the performance is probably the weakest of the three. As throughout the set, tempos tend to be on the sluggish side. A deeper problem is the lack of neurasthenic ‘edge’. The reluctance to force rhythm and sonority into what might be construed as a modernist straitjacket makes for a generalised effect and, at times, elicits a half-hearted response from these great players. The finale must be one of the most boring on disc: Nelsons seems content to let the music jog along rather than driving it towards one massive final climax and the customary dash for the finishing line.

The Sixth is at least interesting. The opening movement is less precipitate than Leonard Bernstein’s in the 1960s without quite emulating the world-weariness of Sir John Barbirolli. Alma’s theme conveys little uplift or liberation, although the horns are pugnacious. The central interlude of Alpine reverie is evocatively done: the cowbells feel ‘authentically’ remote and the mountain glades magically pristine. Transitional passages that start light can turn sticky even as the musicians find their best form. Like Paavo Järvi, Teodor Currentzis, Semyon Bychkov and others, Nelsons believes the Scherzo should be heard second. In this, he is something of an outlier among modern conductors, but then he also repudiates zippier trends in tempo and articulation, unfashionably omitting Deryck Cooke’s performing version of the Tenth from his larger 12-CD intégrale. The Sixth’s inner movements are usually, if not invariably, plainer than Bernstein’s. Nelsons does have a habit of ‘sitting’ on individual notes and some will find the Andante moderato simply too broad. The finale, solemn rather than rip-roaring, features a decently cataclysmic treatment of Mahler’s introduction and a convincing grasp of the architectural trajectory. The sound engineering projects the somewhat overbearing brass sound presumably favoured by the maestro. 

The Seventh, already available on a C Major DVD, fares less well, perhaps because this is music that really does need to be lighter on its feet. Here, the creepiness and the irony are again mixed down in favour of a certain dogged continuity. Nelsons is at his best in the Andante amoroso (Nachtmusik II). The contributions of mandolin and guitar are inconsistently miked, but there is plenty of fluid, characterful woodwind playing, especially lovely towards the movement’s close. The finale suffers from the same issues as the corresponding movement of the Fifth: the music plods along with insufficient contrast or moment-to-moment tension, proving that transparency and polish can only take us so far. Given that the Vienna Philharmonic has been playing these works with finesse since the 1970s, it isn’t immediately obvious what Nelsons is bringing to the table.

1 thought on “The central Mahler Symphonies in uninspiring performances from Nelsons and the VPO”

  1. I can’t unhear how at 4:34 in the last track of the first movement of Mahler 7, the bass drum player enters 4 bars early. And the video performance on Stage+ does not have this error. Sucks that they chose this take for the album…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *