Charpentier
David and Jonathan – Opera in a prologue and five acts to a libretto by François de Paule Bretonneau [sung in an English translation by Christopher Cowell]
David – Harun Ellis Tekin
Jonathan – Tom Lilburn
Saul – Massimo Modoni
Samuel/Achis – Daniel Chomiak
Pythoness – Nadiia Chaichenko
Joabel – Ambroise Chiu
Soldiers/Prisoners/Followers – Hope Heaven, Judy Mackerass, Rachel Rogers, Zachary MacArthur, Denzel Bruhn, Yvonne Lloyds, Rose Dands, Claire Campbell & David Balica
Chorus of New Sussex Opera
Bellot Ensemble
Toby Purser
Paul Higgins – Director
Mollie Cheek – Designer
Daisy Hardwick – Lighting designer
Namiko Gahier-Ogawa – Choreography
Benjamin Poore – Dramaturg
Reviewed by: Curtis Rogers
Reviewed: 11 October, 2026
Venue: Windmill Theatre, Hove, East Sussex, UK
This is New Sussex Opera’s first foray into the French Baroque and, despite a work which isn’t the most accessible from that repertoire, the company brings it to life with simple, vivid effectiveness. Not strictly an opera, but rather a Biblical or sacred drama, it was written by Charpentier in 1688 for performance at the Jesuit Collège Louis-le-Grand (renamed, in rather self-aggrandising Trumpian fashion, after the then-reigning monarch). Its five Acts were interspersed with a now lost Latin play, Saul, dealing with the same events in the Old Testament, which explains the lack of a clearer, more detailed narrative in Charpentier’s musical drama, and why, for instance, Saul’s descent into violent madness isn’t depicted more extensively, as it is in Handel’s later oratorio on the same subject. Also, rather than lead up to the troubled king’s encounter with the Witch of Endor as a central climactic point, in Charpentier’s work it forms the Prologue (the latter character here the ‘Pythoness’) setting up an atmosphere of doom and foreboding over everything that follows.
Something of that atmosphere forms the dramaturgical substance of Paul Higgins’s production instead of interposing a more eventful staging or narrative to fill in the text. In the first part (covering the Prologue and the first two Acts) a wind and thunder machine stand at each side of the otherwise empty stage to add their exhilarating accompaniment at relevant moments. For the remaining Acts in the second part, a stone tomb inscribed with ‘Et in Arcadia ego’ reproduces exactly the scene in Poussin’s painting of the same name, as a proleptic memorial to the slain Saul and his son, Jonathan, as well as all the other victims of the wars which play out in the background to this Biblical episode. To all of this is a scenic backdrop of nuclear-looking swirls of clouds or smoke, denoting the waste and destruction of war, variously illumined in different scenes.
The framework of conflict is updated here to the Second World War on the part of the chorus and most of the principals, with David, Jonathan, and Achis each a representative of the air force, navy, and army respectively. David, in a silvery, silken shirt, and Jonathan, with golden ornamentation on his, add a semblance of glamour amidst that austerity in the celebratory scene at the end of Act Two in which they lead the dancing, alluding to the intense homosocial character of their relationship, if not explicitly erotic. This updating dovetails with the Baroque character of the original insofar as Saul is dressed in courtly attire of the late 17th century, complete with long curly wig, paradoxically introducing a more theatrically camp element than anything David and Jonathan bring, even if the latter in white naval uniform is vaguely reminiscent of Noël Coward improbably attempting to be butch in the Wartime film In Which We Serve.
Compared with most other French Baroque musical drama, this work contains mercifully few interludes for dancing; the handful of such numbers are either integrated in the drama, as described above, or otherwise their music creates a sense of frenzied activity which appropriately embodies the noise of war. The rhythmic impulse of those parts of the score informs the lively and alert performance from the period instrument Bellot Ensemble and conductor Toby Purser, lending a stylish sense of unity in this realisation of the work. They sustain a foot-tapping momentum throughout each half, forging the separate episodes of each Act into a more coherent, continuous whole. The muted sonorities of the strings, in particular, provide a more sorrowful contrast.
Despite the intimacy of the relationship between David and Jonathan witnessed in the drama, Harun Ellis Tekin and Tom Lilburn project bold and communicative musical characters in the title role. Tekin is mellifluous and generally unforced in the haute-contre tenor part of David, while Lilburn fosters the searing glow almost of a male soprano, not simply a countertenor, as Jonathan (whose music was originally written for treble).
Massimo Modoni is a subdued, inward Saul, not at all evoking menace, concentrating on woeful introspection at the expense of outward fury. In the part of the Pythoness, originally written also as a tenor haute-contre in what would have been an all-male environment, Nadiia Chaichenko is suitably androgynous and mellow in tone, depicted as a nurse as she communes with the otherworldly. Other, briefer solo roles are more variable, though never less than enthused. The New Sussex Opera Chorus are equally energetic as they goad the characters on to action, even sometimes despite themselves.
This is another fascinating discovery by this company, and commendably realised in collaboration with the Bellot Ensemble, given that the French Baroque is still hardly essayed by resident groups in this country, leaving it to all-too-rare visits by ensembles from across La Manche.
Further performances in Sussex, London and Winchester to 25 October


A very helpful positive review of the show which I saw at the Cadogan Hall in London. Given the long list of NSO’s previous productions, the ambition of putting on this rarity should not come as a surprise. It was a great achievement and the audience showed its warm appreciation.