San Francisco Symphony – 1
Ives
Symphony No.3 (The Camp Meeting)
Strauss
Salome – Final Scene
Shostakovich
Symphony No.5 in D minor, Op.47
Deborah Voigt (soprano)
San Francisco Symphony
Michael Tilson Thomas
Reviewed by: Kevin Rogers
Reviewed: 1 September, 2007
Venue: Royal Albert Hall, London
A packed house greeted our friends from across the pond for this appetising programme, which, on the whole, did not disappoint.
Charles Ives was a part-time composer; his ‘day job’ was as an insurance broker! His Second Symphony, written at the turn of the twentieth-century, gives an ironic commentary on themes that Ives saw as irrelevant to a young American composer, whereas his gentle Third Symphony, is more conventional. The three-movement work started life as a set of three organ solos before being orchestrated. Mahler, shortly before his death, intended to perform the work but left New York with the fair-copy of the score and it remained unperformed for 35 years (none of Ives’s other symphonies had yet to receive their first performances, either).
Scored for strings, reduced woodwind and brass and bells, the detached soundworld conjured by Michael Tilson Thomas seemed ideal, especially in the pastoral world evoked by the solo offerings from the flute and oboe. The close of the opening movement (‘Old Folks Gatherin’’) demonstrated perfect control – enchanting music-making. The second movement, ‘Children’s Day’ found MTT dancing on the podium, injecting jollity into the music. The last movement, ‘Communion’, allowed the strings, especially, to display the depth of their rich sonorities, and another wonderfully-controlled fade to nothingness, with such delicate bell-playing, caused rapt attention. What a pity certain, very selfish, members of the audience did not allow the rest of us to savour the music – they are more interested in vacuous clapping.
Deborah Voigt’s voice is as strong and emotive as ever and as Salome one believed her every vicious and enticing word – what a perverse joy the Final Scene from “Salome” was, which begins just before the presentation to Salome of John the Baptist’s head on a silver platter and involves her delirious hungering for the body before Herod can bear no more and orders her death. Accompanied by gripping then beautifully (and perversely) seductive music, Voigt gave her all and she projected into this cavernous hall with ease: every syllable was laced with feeling.
A cosmopolitan rather than a Russian sound was produced by the orchestra for the Shostakovich symphony. What the music lacked in bite was made up for in the gentle and contemplative passages, such as in the lyrical sections of the first movement, though MTT’s choices in tempo came unstuck with no individuality between episodes. The closing climactic passages certainly lacked the primitive power they required. The wry scherzo was too warm, lacking swing, though there was a spirited violin solo from the Concertmaster. The Largo fared best evincing hauntingly beautiful, organic growth and the very quiet solos were crystal-clear in their refinement. Quite why MTT did not launch immediately into the finale was bewildering. It not only ruined the close of the Largo (because of the seemingly-requisite loud coughing that punctured any sense of serenity) but it also denied the opening of the final movement its surprise of a fierce and lacerating effect. The close was stately enough in its defiance but the very end needed a hollower edge.
A fitting encore was the overture to Leonard Bernstein’s “Candide”, which really swung and swaggered and was an utter joy. What a pity BBC2 did not broadcast it especially as it was a delayed relay (BBC Radio 3 took the concert live and stayed for the extra item) – some of the irrelevant interval chatter could have been removed instead to make room.



As if saving the best till last, the Proms Saturday Matinee series came to a brilliantly conceived end with this extraordinary snapshot of Benjamin Britten before he was 30. There was one single exception, but the most poignant one of all, in the performance of Colin Matthews’s arrangement of Britten’s heartfelt tribute to the great British horn player, Dennis Brain who died 50 years ago to the day of this concert, on 1 September 1957.The concert first celebrated Britten’s collaborations with W H Auden, a mentor not only in his artistic life but also his private one. They worked together on GPO Film Unit productions and the concert kicked off with one of their most extended pieces from that time, “The Way to the Sea”, originally for a film celebrating the upgrade of the London to Portsmouth line. Britten’s expertise at pastiche is to the fore, from grandiloquence for the Romans on the South Coast to skittish and popular song-like music for the throngs using the trains in the 1930s. Even without the images on film, Auden’s words (and particularly the rhythms replicated with, or from, the music) and Britten’s music conjured up a rather nostalgic view of family holidays and both ancient and naval history, with Samuel West reciting the text.
In between the two film items we had two Britten/Auden song-cycles. First tenor Andrew Kennedy – one of those utterly enthusiastic performers, like Tasmin Little, who can’t help but smile – and Ian Burnside performed “On This Island”, which – though curiously not introduced as such – had its first performance 70 years ago this year on the BBC. Encompassing various moods, the last of five songs – playful in words and music – provided a neat segue into the “Cabaret Songs”, as arranged for chamber ensemble by Daryl Runswick. Here the returning Nash Ensemble and Gardner were joined by the heavily pregnant Christine Rice using her present condition nicely in the first song to illustrate the dangers of love!
Mariss Jansons has been a doughty champion – including two recordings – of Arthur Honegger’s Symphonie liturgique, completed in 1946. The ravages of war and hope for the future inform this gripping and moving work, the best-known of Honegger’s five symphonies, all of which are worth exploring like so much of this superb composer’s output. Jansons paced the opening movement (‘Dies irae’) to deliberate effect, ratcheting-up the tension if not pursuing the most graphic course, but securing a dynamic and detailed response from his Munich-based orchestra that was devoted to the cause. After such tense scurrying and militaristic intrusion, the second movement (‘De profundis clamavi’) brings an attempt at consolation and radiance – the beauty of the music shaped ideally by Jansons without sentimentality or exaggeration – before being ensnared in further conflict, once again set up in this performance as a musical act rather than a programmatic one. Jansons missed a trick by not continuing directly into the finale (‘Dona nobis pacem’) – give a Prom audience the opportunity to cough and it does! Tension needed to be re-established quickly – and was – Jansons driving the ostinato on (potentially the weakest part of this work) and building thrillingly to the dissonant climax, which, if not as stomach-churning as it might have been, certainly exploded (with much visual encouragement from the conductor), the final bars transporting us to another planet, one of peace and ethereal beauty and blessed here with superb solos from flute, piccolo, cello and violin. What a shame that what should have been an extended period of reflective silence, after the music fades to nothing, was intruded upon by someone more interested in applauding.
Beethoven 9 was disappointing. The first movement, however expressive and bejewelled, lacked boundary-breaking tempestuousness and, while cohesive, needed to expand more. The scherzo, seriously compromised by the lack of the so-important second repeat, initially enjoyed a well-chiselled rhythmic profile, required a more rugged approach and the trio was inappropriately dainty. Come the slow movement, with a tempo decidedly ‘without ceremony’, Jansons’s all-through ‘con moto’ gave the music no room to progress when the tempo changes from Adagio (which was never suggested) to Andante and was, throughout, expressively restricted. Rarely has the finale’s turbulent opening sounded so tame, and while the lower-strings’ recitatives brought some intensity and the ‘Ode to Joy’ theme a certain uplift, these were in parentheses, part of a stylised interpretation that sacrificed the spirit for the letter. The Bavarian Radio Chorus, technically superb and impressively blended in quieter passages, was lacklustre in the lustier sections and the four soloists were each distinguished and well-balanced, Michael Volle’s call to attention arresting. Quite why Jansons decided to have an off-stage trumpet, the player then moving a little closer into the Hall, in ‘Froh, wie seine Sonnen fliegen’ (the tenor’s solo), is a mystery; certainly questionable, this distracting and detracting gesture was this resolutely uninvolving, if immaculate, performance’s only novelty.
What if BMW ‘did’ orchestras? Of course they would be sleek and elegant and designed for maximum efficiency. They would happily traverse melodious peaks as well as trip lightly over cobbled dissonance without complaint: reliable, efficient and perfect in every way – but just that little bit boring.
As has become usual, audience-members coughed in the quiet and exposed sections of the music and were a distraction. The use of a ‘church bell’, rang true without a hint of a harmonic and provided a focus on the control that made this performance one of the most memorable this Proms season but also enshrined what was is this work’s greatest flaw. Strauss’s depiction of Nietzschean philosophy sets man against nature with man struggling to break free, including a flight into the ether and a climatic attack which is firmly quashed by nature with a resolute C major chord. This is a piece that requires a little chaos and Mariss Jansons as Übermensch, as incredible as he is, did not allow this madness to escape.
In his second, most welcome, Prom of the season, Oliver Knussen conducted the Birmingham Contemporary Music Group (of which he is artist in association) in an exquisite late-night programme, including two of his own works.
The conjunction between Monday’s lunchtime concert (‘Songs of a Rhineland Harper’), reviewed by myself, given by Sequentia of music at least 1,000 years old (however conjectural the re-constructions) and this late-night concert’s final piece also heightened my enjoyment. Given that Julian Anderson’s Book of Hours references medieval art and music and each of the two movements are, respectively, concerned with time and memory, the music of the Harper seemed not that far away.
The Prokofiev performances were both extraordinary as might be expected from this source. Alexander Toradze is an eccentric pianist who was able to demonstrate the full range of his sonority in the Second Piano Concerto. He is, as is well known, a thumper, yet he can also scale down his sound to the merest tinkle. The problem being that the extreme rubato he favoured here frequently disrupted any sense of line. What was left was a kind of fantastic improvisation in which lyrical passages were encouraged to blur and smudge. The first movement’s opening theme was broken-backed by design and the noisily crazed cadenza approached in a mood of disconnected, dreamlike reverie, an atmosphere quickly restored with the LSO’s help to close the movement. The faster music, like the march-like ‘Intermezzo’ placed third was the most predictably treated, though accents could be thrown about in all directions, compromising the composer’s motoric intent. The finale’s echt Russian theme was again distended into a rapt evocation of better times. Conductor and soloist eschewed conventional evening dress but then this was scarcely a conventional reading.
Gergiev’s thrustful, no nonsense interpretation of Prokofiev’s autumnal Seventh Symphony takes a different line in music that can come across as lame or limp in less committed hands. This was the highlight of the evening, demonstrating a real rapport between the players and the charismatic maestro who is giving them at least some of his time. Bland is the last word one could use to describe such music-making, and antiphonally placed violins did not disguise the bigger sound Gergiev is drawing from the whole string section. Wind interventions were uniformly characterful. A pity that there was no space for the optimistic final flourish Prokofiev tacked onto his Symphony in pursuit of Stalin Prize winnings. It would have made a good encore, though there’s enough toughness and disquiet in Gergiev’s conception of the work to make its omission feel right in context. Andrew Huth’s programme note wisely refrained from going too far in portraying the composer’s necessarily muted farewell as an exercise in musical double-speak.
This Prom was set to be one of the most controversial of the 2007 season. Cries of “dumbing down” were made almost before the Prospectus was published. Michael Ball, star of musical theatre, was to have his own Prom and the classical music audience was up in arms, or at least this is what the press would have you believe.
Many well-known and hummable numbers were included in this Prom. Jule Styne and Stephen Sondheim from the Broadway tradition vied with new-pretenders from Europe – Benny Andersson and Andrew Lloyd Webber (both of whom, it is easy to forget, have now been writing hit musicals for over thirty years). In between, a strange choice of the campest of camp renditions of “If you are anxious for to shine’ from “Patience” and the duet ‘Au fond du temple saint’ from “The Pearl Fishers” made for unpalatable listening, if only for the distorted use of amplification that plagued the whole concert.
Alfie Boe, known as Alfred before he was whipped off to Broadway to play in Baz Luhrmann’s production of “La bohème”, is the darling of Classic FM and none the worse for being so. Sadly the choice of singing ‘Au fond du temple saint’ was not a good one, and one that clearly demonstrated Ball’s lack of vocal training with the latter’s clipped phrases and mis-tuned high notes standing proud next to Boe’s well-honed classical technique. Boe’s solo that followed however was delightful within the restraints that the whole stage was amplified and we were denied the opportunity to hear the real marvel of his natural tenor voice.