2007

4868 1

San Francisco Symphony – 1

Ives
Symphony No.3 (The Camp Meeting)
Strauss
Salome – Final Scene
Shostakovich
Symphony No.5 in D minor, Op.47

Deborah Voigt (soprano)

San Francisco Symphony
Michael Tilson Thomas


Reviewed by: Kevin Rogers

Reviewed: 1 September, 2007
Venue: Royal Albert Hall, London

A packed house greeted our friends from across the pond for this appetising programme, which, on the whole, did not disappoint.

Charles Ives (1874-1954). Photograph: Clara SipprellCharles Ives was a part-time composer; his ‘day job’ was as an insurance broker! His Second Symphony, written at the turn of the twentieth-century, gives an ironic commentary on themes that Ives saw as irrelevant to a young American composer, whereas his gentle Third Symphony, is more conventional. The three-movement work started life as a set of three organ solos before being orchestrated. Mahler, shortly before his death, intended to perform the work but left New York with the fair-copy of the score and it remained unperformed for 35 years (none of Ives’s other symphonies had yet to receive their first performances, either).

Scored for strings, reduced woodwind and brass and bells, the detached soundworld conjured by Michael Tilson Thomas seemed ideal, especially in the pastoral world evoked by the solo offerings from the flute and oboe. The close of the opening movement (‘Old Folks Gatherin’’) demonstrated perfect control – enchanting music-making. The second movement, ‘Children’s Day’ found MTT dancing on the podium, injecting jollity into the music. The last movement, ‘Communion’, allowed the strings, especially, to display the depth of their rich sonorities, and another wonderfully-controlled fade to nothingness, with such delicate bell-playing, caused rapt attention. What a pity certain, very selfish, members of the audience did not allow the rest of us to savour the music – they are more interested in vacuous clapping.

Sporano Deborah Voight. © Joanne SavioDeborah Voigt’s voice is as strong and emotive as ever and as Salome one believed her every vicious and enticing word – what a perverse joy the Final Scene from “Salome” was, which begins just before the presentation to Salome of John the Baptist’s head on a silver platter and involves her delirious hungering for the body before Herod can bear no more and orders her death. Accompanied by gripping then beautifully (and perversely) seductive music, Voigt gave her all and she projected into this cavernous hall with ease: every syllable was laced with feeling.

A cosmopolitan rather than a Russian sound was produced by the orchestra for the Shostakovich symphony. What the music lacked in bite was made up for in the gentle and contemplative passages, such as in the lyrical sections of the first movement, though MTT’s choices in tempo came unstuck with no individuality between episodes. The closing climactic passages certainly lacked the primitive power they required. The wry scherzo was too warm, lacking swing, though there was a spirited violin solo from the Concertmaster. The Largo fared best evincing hauntingly beautiful, organic growth and the very quiet solos were crystal-clear in their refinement. Quite why MTT did not launch immediately into the finale was bewildering. It not only ruined the close of the Largo (because of the seemingly-requisite loud coughing that punctured any sense of serenity) but it also denied the opening of the final movement its surprise of a fierce and lacerating effect. The close was stately enough in its defiance but the very end needed a hollower edge.

A fitting encore was the overture to Leonard Bernstein’s “Candide”, which really swung and swaggered and was an utter joy. What a pity BBC2 did not broadcast it especially as it was a delayed relay (BBC Radio 3 took the concert live and stayed for the extra item) – some of the irrelevant interval chatter could have been removed instead to make room.

San Francisco Symphony – 1 Read More »

4874 1

Britten & Auden

Britten
The Way to the Sea
On This Island, Op.11
Cabaret Songs [arr. Daryl Runswick]
Night Mail
Britten, arr. Colin Matthews
In memoriam Dennis Brain [London premiere]
Britten
Serenade for Tenor, Horn and Strings, Op.31

Samuel West (narrator)

Andrew Kennedy (tenor)

Christine Rice (mezzo-soprano)

Ian Burnside (piano)

Richard Watkins, Nigel Black, Michael Thompson & Laurence Davies (horns)

Nash Ensemble
Edward Gardner


Reviewed by: Nick Breckenfield

Reviewed: 1 September, 2007
Venue: Cadogan Hall, London

Benjamin Britten (1913-76)As if saving the best till last, the Proms Saturday Matinee series came to a brilliantly conceived end with this extraordinary snapshot of Benjamin Britten before he was 30. There was one single exception, but the most poignant one of all, in the performance of Colin Matthews’s arrangement of Britten’s heartfelt tribute to the great British horn player, Dennis Brain who died 50 years ago to the day of this concert, on 1 September 1957.The concert first celebrated Britten’s collaborations with W H Auden, a mentor not only in his artistic life but also his private one. They worked together on GPO Film Unit productions and the concert kicked off with one of their most extended pieces from that time, “The Way to the Sea”, originally for a film celebrating the upgrade of the London to Portsmouth line. Britten’s expertise at pastiche is to the fore, from grandiloquence for the Romans on the South Coast to skittish and popular song-like music for the throngs using the trains in the 1930s. Even without the images on film, Auden’s words (and particularly the rhythms replicated with, or from, the music) and Britten’s music conjured up a rather nostalgic view of family holidays and both ancient and naval history, with Samuel West reciting the text.

West later returned to introduce the centrepiece of the concert: excerpts (beginning and end) of Britten and Auden’s most famous collaboration, “Night Mail”. The final shots, of the train arriving in Glasgow and the workers cleaning the locomotives is overlaid by Auden’s paean to the power letter-writing, affecting various people in various ways, when Britten was at his most Waltonesque (vis-à-vis “Façade”). There was a minor irritation with West’s head microphone, with which he didn’t seem all that happy and didn’t work too well in the Hall, which is surely small enough for a standing microphone only, if that.

One thing was missing in the various introductions: how extraordinarily pioneering these films were, given that sound in movies was still very much in its infancy. How complicated is the co-ordination between film, words and music was shown by Edward Gardner’s use of a click-track (although West tried to persuade us that it was to do with the film elves).

Christine Rice In between the two film items we had two Britten/Auden song-cycles. First tenor Andrew Kennedy – one of those utterly enthusiastic performers, like Tasmin Little, who can’t help but smile – and Ian Burnside performed “On This Island”, which – though curiously not introduced as such – had its first performance 70 years ago this year on the BBC. Encompassing various moods, the last of five songs – playful in words and music – provided a neat segue into the “Cabaret Songs”, as arranged for chamber ensemble by Daryl Runswick. Here the returning Nash Ensemble and Gardner were joined by the heavily pregnant Christine Rice using her present condition nicely in the first song to illustrate the dangers of love!

The turn from Auden to Dennis Brain brought Colin Matthews’s sympathetic arrangement of an unfinished work that Britten had felt too devastated to complete. His In memoriam Dennis Brain – in effect an introduction and allegro for four horns and ensemble – was utterly affecting 50 years to the day since Brain was killed in a car crash. Richard Watkins, once, like Dennis Brain before him, a Philharmonia Orchestra principal horn player, was joined by a trio of other such alumni.

Only one work could follow – Britten’s Serenade for Tenor, Horn and Strings, with Richard Watkins joined by Andrew Kennedy. After Gardner had introduced the work, Watkins played the horn part from memory, adding to the intensity of the performance, with Kennedy’s fine English tenor beautifully matched. Composed for Peter Pears in 1943 – the year of Britten’s 30th-birthday – it brought this concert to a spine-tingling close, having offered an unusual, almost corrective, view of early Britten.

Britten & Auden Read More »

Two’s Company

Musgrave
Two’s Company [BBC commission: world premiere]
Mahler
Symphony No.1

Nicholas Daniel (oboe) & Dame Evelyn Glennie (percussion)

BBC Symphony Orchestra
Jiří Bělohlávek


Reviewed by: Steve Lomas

Reviewed: 31 August, 2007
Venue: Royal Albert Hall, London

Although there are notable works for oboe and percussion by Birtwistle and Xenakis, Thea Musgrave’s Two’s Company – the last of the BBC’s commissions for Proms 2007 – could well be the first-ever concerto for the combination (I hope some perspicacious reader will prove me wrong on this). It is the latest in a long line of works by Musgrave to explore what she refers to as the ‘dramatic-abstract’, an approach to form in which spatial movement and physical gestures are enacted by the performers but without programmatic content. Composers who operate in this area (Birtwistle and Xenakis for instance!) often seek to evoke an atavistic connection with the principles of ancient Greek theatre but Musgrave tends more to the urbane and so it is with the new work.

The stage-setting as the performance begins has four percussion stations, two at the front of the smallish orchestra and two at the rear. The percussion soloist occupies the one at the front-right – with no sign of the oboist. The orchestra unfolds a slow, ruminative tapestry of interlocking lines with part-writing of marvellous subtlety. The soloist initially discharges the function of an orchestral percussionist (there are none otherwise), adding delicate splashes of colour on gong and chimes. Enter the oboe soloist from the left of the auditorium, interrupting the orchestral flow with a forlorn soliloquy.

The work then plays out – and thereby delineates its form – as a coy ritual of courtship. The percussionist deploys various strategies to attract the attention of the easily distracted oboist (who has infiltrated the orchestra), moving first to a vibraphone at the rear-right and then to a drum-kit rear-left. Inevitably this latter yields the most propulsive music so far and a catharsis, in the fall-out of which the oboe at last opens up to the percussion and the two – now physically adjacent with the percussionist on marimba – intertwine ever-more closely in an imitative dialogue, finally reaching an unanticipated resolution with a cadence on a major triad.

With the drama of the concerto focussing essentially on the relationship between the two soloists, the role of the orchestra is subordinated to that of facilitator, supplying harmonic fields and melodic patterns in which the soloists work out their drama. The orchestra is in effect the platform on which the soloists perform. From time to time a solo instrument or group calls out from within the orchestra, interacting with the soloists (usually the oboist) in the manner of a subsidiary character or prop.

Without a score I was not sure if the modicum of physical acting – longing glances and at one point the percussionist leading the oboist by the hand – is written into the piece. I could imagine a more hieratic approach to this aspect with all movement formalised in the manner of a Noh play. It is also tempting to speculate how the implied (with these particular performers) heterosexual mating game would play out with other combinations of performer gender!

Musgrave’s compositional art is supremely fluent and almost in danger of being taken for granted these days. The musical language of Two’s Company is elegant, soft-hued, witty and altogether ‘late manner’. Speaking from a recent immersion of my own in the operas of Richard Strauss, if Musgrave’s visceral Horn Concerto is “Elektra”, then Two’s Company was “Capriccio”, a civilised discourse about the nature of discourse.

The soloists could hardly be improved upon. Nicholas Daniel, for whom Musgrave wrote her 1995 oboe concerto Helios, performed miracles of tonal control and effortless virtuosity in his familiar unflappable manner. Evelyn Glennie reined in her sometimes-distracting self-absorption in the service of the greater whole. The writing may not have been the most challenging she has ever worked with but the emotional arc of her part was perfectly captured. The BBC Symphony Orchestra under its Chief Conductor Jiří Bělohlávek contributed a well-drilled underpinning.

My only complaint about Two’s Company is its irritatingly glib title, reminiscent of the kind popular with certain young British composers in the 1980s – Mixed Doubles, Parallel Bars et al. Otherwise I predict a healthy future for the 20-minute work.

I found the performance of Mahler 1 a frustratingly uneven affair.

The should-be magical opening was distinctly earthbound, with ragged unisons, sour tuning and poorly-shaded dynamics, which were also to feature elsewhere in the account. The leaden tempo of the outer panels of the second movement created contrast problems, in that we seemed to be re-treading much of the ground of the first movement and the central Ländler had to be taken at an even slower pace verging on the dirge-like.

Set against that, the dreamy major-key interlude in the third movement was wonderfully tender and the much-deferred peroration of the finale was genuinely thrilling. As was the terrifying beginning of that movement, which seems to presage the birth of modernity in music and was to be so influential on the young Schoenberg.

A serviceable performance overall but Abbado and the Lucerne Festival Orchestra had too recently shown what a Mahler performance should really sound like.

Two’s Company Read More »

4857 1

Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra – 2

Honegger
Symphonie liturgique (Symphony No.3)
Beethoven
Symphony No.9 in D minor, Op.125 (Choral)

Krassimira Stoyanova (soprano)
Lioba Braun (mezzo-soprano)
Michael Schade (tenor)
Michael Volle (baritone)

Bavarian Radio Symphony Chorus

Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra
Mariss Jansons


Reviewed by: Colin Anderson

Reviewed: 30 August, 2007
Venue: Royal Albert Hall, London

Two very different symphonies, generously coupled here in the second of the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra’s two Proms, that seek reconciliation; Honegger through a suggestion of paradise after violent strife and Beethoven offering a paean of praise for the brotherhood of man.

Arthur Honegger (1892-1955)Mariss Jansons has been a doughty champion – including two recordings – of Arthur Honegger’s Symphonie liturgique, completed in 1946. The ravages of war and hope for the future inform this gripping and moving work, the best-known of Honegger’s five symphonies, all of which are worth exploring like so much of this superb composer’s output. Jansons paced the opening movement (‘Dies irae’) to deliberate effect, ratcheting-up the tension if not pursuing the most graphic course, but securing a dynamic and detailed response from his Munich-based orchestra that was devoted to the cause. After such tense scurrying and militaristic intrusion, the second movement (‘De profundis clamavi’) brings an attempt at consolation and radiance – the beauty of the music shaped ideally by Jansons without sentimentality or exaggeration – before being ensnared in further conflict, once again set up in this performance as a musical act rather than a programmatic one. Jansons missed a trick by not continuing directly into the finale (‘Dona nobis pacem’) – give a Prom audience the opportunity to cough and it does! Tension needed to be re-established quickly – and was – Jansons driving the ostinato on (potentially the weakest part of this work) and building thrillingly to the dissonant climax, which, if not as stomach-churning as it might have been, certainly exploded (with much visual encouragement from the conductor), the final bars transporting us to another planet, one of peace and ethereal beauty and blessed here with superb solos from flute, piccolo, cello and violin. What a shame that what should have been an extended period of reflective silence, after the music fades to nothing, was intruded upon by someone more interested in applauding.

Mariss Jansons. Photograph: Reuters/ScanpixBeethoven 9 was disappointing. The first movement, however expressive and bejewelled, lacked boundary-breaking tempestuousness and, while cohesive, needed to expand more. The scherzo, seriously compromised by the lack of the so-important second repeat, initially enjoyed a well-chiselled rhythmic profile, required a more rugged approach and the trio was inappropriately dainty. Come the slow movement, with a tempo decidedly ‘without ceremony’, Jansons’s all-through ‘con moto’ gave the music no room to progress when the tempo changes from Adagio (which was never suggested) to Andante and was, throughout, expressively restricted. Rarely has the finale’s turbulent opening sounded so tame, and while the lower-strings’ recitatives brought some intensity and the ‘Ode to Joy’ theme a certain uplift, these were in parentheses, part of a stylised interpretation that sacrificed the spirit for the letter. The Bavarian Radio Chorus, technically superb and impressively blended in quieter passages, was lacklustre in the lustier sections and the four soloists were each distinguished and well-balanced, Michael Volle’s call to attention arresting. Quite why Jansons decided to have an off-stage trumpet, the player then moving a little closer into the Hall, in ‘Froh, wie seine Sonnen fliegen’ (the tenor’s solo), is a mystery; certainly questionable, this distracting and detracting gesture was this resolutely uninvolving, if immaculate, performance’s only novelty.

Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra – 2 Read More »

4887 1

Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra – 1

Strauss
Also sprach Zarathustra, Op.30
Sibelius
Symphony No.2 in D, Op.43

Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra
Mariss Jansons


Reviewed by: Chris Caspell

Reviewed: 29 August, 2007
Venue: Royal Albert Hall, London

Mariss Jansons. ©Markus DlouhyWhat if BMW ‘did’ orchestras? Of course they would be sleek and elegant and designed for maximum efficiency. They would happily traverse melodious peaks as well as trip lightly over cobbled dissonance without complaint: reliable, efficient and perfect in every way – but just that little bit boring.

News had got out that this concert was going to be something to see … there was hardly a spare seat in the packed Royal Albert Hall. The Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra brought its own organ (for the ‘2001’ opening to the Strauss) rather than use the Hall’s own – due to any potential difference in pitch – the effect was visually unexpected and audibly underwhelming.

After a ‘Sunrise’ on steroids, the tempo settled down to produce an exemplary performance with a notably lush sound from the strings and a judicious observance of dynamic markings. The winds and brass were compacted onto the platform with the horns and trumpets placed in front of each other two abreast rather than spread out across the back. This made the orchestra appear smaller than it was, but the sound was much more intense and rich as a consequence.

Richard StraussAs has become usual, audience-members coughed in the quiet and exposed sections of the music and were a distraction. The use of a ‘church bell’, rang true without a hint of a harmonic and provided a focus on the control that made this performance one of the most memorable this Proms season but also enshrined what was is this work’s greatest flaw. Strauss’s depiction of Nietzschean philosophy sets man against nature with man struggling to break free, including a flight into the ether and a climatic attack which is firmly quashed by nature with a resolute C major chord. This is a piece that requires a little chaos and Mariss Jansons as Übermensch, as incredible as he is, did not allow this madness to escape.

As he did with the Oslo Philharmonic during the 1995 Proms, Jansons paired Zarathustra with one of the 20th-century’s great symphonists – and the same symphony, too. Stephen Johnson’s programme note described a series of meetings in 1907 between Sibelius and another great symphony-compose, Mahler. According to Sibelius they discussed the form of the symphony with the Finn admiring severity of style and logic whereas Mahler believed that “the symphony must be like the world. It must embrace everything”. Despite his embracing of formality, Sibelius’s music cannot be criticised for not being all-embracing.

Jansons’s view of Sibelius’s Second Symphony was classically reserved, exquisite in terms of precision, but lacked soul – especially in the first movement; in the second that ‘wall of sound’ was again to the fore in a well-balanced, finely-tuned rendition. Rubato, de rigueur in this movement, was expertly controlled. A well-articulated third movement, counterpoint lifting effortlessly from the page, lead to a climatic finale that turned disappointment into delight. There were a couple of issues of co-ordination, but these were quickly overcome to produce a crowning coda.

The BRSO’s strings were put to exquisite use in Sibelius’s Valse triste, and as an antidote to a tonality and romanticism the second encore was drawn from Bartók’s The Miraculous Mandarin (the ‘chase music’ that ends the Suite), the caustic dissonance refreshing after such rich harmonic pleasure and a somewhat mixed concert.

Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra – 1 Read More »

4860 1

Ophelia Dances … Songs for Sue … Book of Hours

Knussen
Ophelia Dances
Webern
Five Pieces for Orchestra, Op.10
Knussen
Requiem – Songs for Sue
Julian Anderson
Book of Hours

Claire Booth (soprano)

Birmingham Contemporary Music Group
Oliver Knussen


Reviewed by: Nick Breckenfield

Reviewed: 29 August, 2007
Venue: Royal Albert Hall, London

Oliver Knussen. Photograph: Mykol NicolaouIn his second, most welcome, Prom of the season, Oliver Knussen conducted the Birmingham Contemporary Music Group (of which he is artist in association) in an exquisite late-night programme, including two of his own works.

Ophelia Dances (actually indicated as ‘Book One’, although no further book has ever appeared) features a celesta in central position with four wind (flute, oboe, clarinet and horn) to the left and three strings to the right, plus percussion. It’s a glistening score, crystal-clear across the vast expanses of the Royal Albert Hall, yet so pure in its intimacy, a beguiling addition to the ‘Shakespeare in music’ theme this Proms year.

Equally delicate was not one but two superb performances of Webern’s Five Pieces for Orchestra, Opus 10, not requiring the huge forces of Schoenberg’s similarly titled work that Knussen had conducted with the BBC Symphony Orchestra earlier this season. With just 19 players (only rising to a collective climax in the third and fifth pieces), and with one of the pieces just seven bars long, these are microscopic creations that have maximum impact. At the end Knussen turned and announced “And again” – the wonder of these pieces being their seemingly different contours even when heard in such close juxtaposition.

With efficient between-work changes, the platform was quickly re-arranged for Knussen’s “Requiem – Songs for Sue”, composed in memory of his wife, Sue. Using words by Emily Dickinson (opening with the heart-stopping line, “Is it true, dear Sue?”) amalgamated by the composer, Machado’s “Cuanado murió su amada” (When his beloved died) and W. H. Auden’s “Time will say nothing but I told you so”, Knussen’s song-cycle inspired by Alexander Goehr’s choice of a Rilke poem in Sue’s memory – “Biss du noch da?” (Are you still there?), which now forms the last song.

Beautifully sung by Claire Booth there seemed an additional layer added to the performance’s meaning, given that Booth is pregnant. Somehow the promise of new life so visibly connected to the memory of a lost life made the occasion all the more poignant.

Julian AndersonThe conjunction between Monday’s lunchtime concert (‘Songs of a Rhineland Harper’), reviewed by myself, given by Sequentia of music at least 1,000 years old (however conjectural the re-constructions) and this late-night concert’s final piece also heightened my enjoyment. Given that Julian Anderson’s Book of Hours references medieval art and music and each of the two movements are, respectively, concerned with time and memory, the music of the Harper seemed not that far away.

What is wonderful about Anderson’s work is his use of electronics (controlled by the composer, and others, at the back of the Arena, where he is a regular presence), which are used as subtly as any instrument. Book of Hours is a rhythmic delight, connecting Anderson recognisably within the tradition of music, but also creating a wonderfully distinct piece which, although perhaps working best on a recording (especially the second part’s introduction of a clicking shellac record), is great to hear live. It’s a witty, mechanical music-box of a piece that was given a winning performance by Knussen and the players of the BCMG, who premièred it (as part of its “Sound Investment” initiative) and recorded it.

It brought this well-nigh-perfect late-night Prom to a terrific close; it’s relatively small, but wonderfully enthusiastic audience satisfied.

Ophelia Dances … Songs for Sue … Book of Hours Read More »

4853 1

LSO/Gergiev

Tchaikovsky
Romeo and Juliet – Fantasy Overture after Shakespeare
Prokofiev
Piano Concerto No.2 in G minor, Op.16
Tchaikovsky
Hamlet – Fantasy Overture after Shakespeare, Op.67
Prokofiev
Symphony No.7 in C sharp minor, Op.131

Alexander Toradze (piano)

London Symphony Orchestra
Valery Gergiev


Reviewed by: David Gutman

Reviewed: 28 August, 2007
Venue: Royal Albert Hall, London

Coming so soon after Claudio Abbado’s display of perfectionism (Lucerne Festival Orchestra Mahler 3), it was as well to be reminded that there’s more than one way to skin a bear. Whether merely grunting, singing along lustily or using his customary shimmery semaphore, Valery Gergiev blazed a trail for a more visceral brand of music-making.

Not that all the performances actually worked. The Tchaikovsky items seemed to have been included mainly to comply with the season’s Shakespearean theme. Romeo and Juliet was taut and goal-directed but generalised – it was difficult to believe that too much rehearsal time had been expended on it. Hamlet seemed more persuasive – or was it simply that we don’t know it so well?

Alexander Toradze. Photograph: IU South Bend Department of External AffairsThe Prokofiev performances were both extraordinary as might be expected from this source. Alexander Toradze is an eccentric pianist who was able to demonstrate the full range of his sonority in the Second Piano Concerto. He is, as is well known, a thumper, yet he can also scale down his sound to the merest tinkle. The problem being that the extreme rubato he favoured here frequently disrupted any sense of line. What was left was a kind of fantastic improvisation in which lyrical passages were encouraged to blur and smudge. The first movement’s opening theme was broken-backed by design and the noisily crazed cadenza approached in a mood of disconnected, dreamlike reverie, an atmosphere quickly restored with the LSO’s help to close the movement. The faster music, like the march-like ‘Intermezzo’ placed third was the most predictably treated, though accents could be thrown about in all directions, compromising the composer’s motoric intent. The finale’s echt Russian theme was again distended into a rapt evocation of better times. Conductor and soloist eschewed conventional evening dress but then this was scarcely a conventional reading.

The last photograph of Sergei Prokofiev, take in 1952. Source: Sviatoslav ProkofievGergiev’s thrustful, no nonsense interpretation of Prokofiev’s autumnal Seventh Symphony takes a different line in music that can come across as lame or limp in less committed hands. This was the highlight of the evening, demonstrating a real rapport between the players and the charismatic maestro who is giving them at least some of his time. Bland is the last word one could use to describe such music-making, and antiphonally placed violins did not disguise the bigger sound Gergiev is drawing from the whole string section. Wind interventions were uniformly characterful. A pity that there was no space for the optimistic final flourish Prokofiev tacked onto his Symphony in pursuit of Stalin Prize winnings. It would have made a good encore, though there’s enough toughness and disquiet in Gergiev’s conception of the work to make its omission feel right in context. Andrew Huth’s programme note wisely refrained from going too far in portraying the composer’s necessarily muted farewell as an exercise in musical double-speak.

For those interested in such things, the BBC’s cameras were not too intrusive on this occasion even if lighting designs were characteristically objectionable. The audience applauded in all the right places, too. No mobile phone incidents but someone somewhere could not be dissuaded from dropping things loudly and repeatedly. Who are these people and can they not be hunted down?

LSO/Gergiev Read More »

4850 1

An Evening with Michael Ball

Music from Jekyll & Hyde, Funny Girl, Patience, West Side Story, Patience, Kismet, The Pearl Fishers, Godspell, Jesus Christ Superstar, Sunset Boulevard, Chess, The Phantom of the Opera, Les Misérables, Passion, and others

Michael Ball (singer) with Alfie Boe (tenor), Laura Michelle Kelly (singer) & Izzy Johnston (violin)

Capital Voices

BBC Concert Orchestra
Callum McLeod


Reviewed by: Chris Caspell

Reviewed: 27 August, 2007
Venue: Royal Albert Hall, London

Michael BallThis Prom was set to be one of the most controversial of the 2007 season. Cries of “dumbing down” were made almost before the Prospectus was published. Michael Ball, star of musical theatre, was to have his own Prom and the classical music audience was up in arms, or at least this is what the press would have you believe.

The day after the concert, a glance at the BBC Radio 3 message-board continues the controversy: over two-hundred messages with fans of Ball declaring the concert a triumph over “snobbish” classical music lovers who in turn said they avoided listening as the music was bound to be inferior to other concerts at the Proms.

But the Proms has long been a broad church. It is therefore peculiar that the out-going Controller, Nicholas Kenyon, has taken so much flack over Ball’s appearance.

The Hall was a sell-out in terms of seated members even if the Arena and Gallery were nearly empty. This was a different kind of audience – one made up, in the main, by the middle-aged fan-base that Ball has built over 20 years. Ladies of a certain age whom once might have considered throwing their knickers and swooning at their pop-idols looked as though they were considering doing the same again. Ball’s encouragement whipped the gathering to fever-pitch and he could have sung “Three Blind Mice” out of tune and still have received the standing ovation that followed every piece.

Georges Bizet (1838-75), composer of 'The Pearl Fishers'Many well-known and hummable numbers were included in this Prom. Jule Styne and Stephen Sondheim from the Broadway tradition vied with new-pretenders from Europe – Benny Andersson and Andrew Lloyd Webber (both of whom, it is easy to forget, have now been writing hit musicals for over thirty years). In between, a strange choice of the campest of camp renditions of “If you are anxious for to shine’ from “Patience” and the duet ‘Au fond du temple saint’ from “The Pearl Fishers” made for unpalatable listening, if only for the distorted use of amplification that plagued the whole concert.

A concert such as this can be made or slain by the sound engineers and their skill, or lack of it, in making the instruments, including the voice, natural and in fact seeming to be non-amplified. I am unsure what the problems were but, in short, the sound balance was catastrophic. The strings, in the louder numbers, were mere eye-candy and inaudible; the brass, drum-kit and electronic instruments dominated producing volume that was unattractive and often with very little musical merit.

The tenor Alfie BoeAlfie Boe, known as Alfred before he was whipped off to Broadway to play in Baz Luhrmann’s production of “La bohème”, is the darling of Classic FM and none the worse for being so. Sadly the choice of singing ‘Au fond du temple saint’ was not a good one, and one that clearly demonstrated Ball’s lack of vocal training with the latter’s clipped phrases and mis-tuned high notes standing proud next to Boe’s well-honed classical technique. Boe’s solo that followed however was delightful within the restraints that the whole stage was amplified and we were denied the opportunity to hear the real marvel of his natural tenor voice.

A dig was made at the elitism of the Proms, subtly in ‘Feeling Good’ – from a musical vaudeville piece about the British class system and more overtly in Ball’s comments before the selection from “Patience”. Was this necessary? If anything his comments increased any perceived gap between so-called “high art” and “pop music”; maybe he didn’t really mean what he said. At the end of the concert, just before John Miles’s seminal anthem “Music”, Ball called to all lovers of good music be they from the classical, rock, jazz or stage genres and embrace what is good within that art-form. I whole-heartedly agree with this sentiment and salute the differences that make music so varied and exciting.

The delight of the evening came with the introduction of Laura Michelle Kennedy, currently singing the part of Galadriel in “The Lord of the Rings” at the Theatre Royal, Drury Lane. At the age of 27 she is no newcomer to musical theatre having received critical acclaim for the role of Mary Poppins. She made her West End debut at just 17 in “Beauty and the Beast” where she met her husband, choreographer Nick Winston. Kennedy’s duet with Ball saw her as a dynamic and infectious performer who was more than equal to the task: matching Ball for style and energy in this upbeat number by Carole Bayer Sager. Once again poor sound marred this engaging performance with both singers being swamped by an over-amplified BBC Concert Orchestra.

The anthem to Music itself, written by John Miles and the musician’s best-known hit (reaching the top 3 in 1976), was a natural ending to the night’s festivities. Ball recorded it on his 2005 album of the same name and warms naturally to the range and style of the piece. Violinist Izzy Johnston’s performance at the back of the stage was easily missed – again due to poor amplification – and the piece was clearly more dedicated to stage-craft (Ball’s playing the timpani about half-way through) than to careful musical precision. Nevertheless the audience lapped it up. As an encore Michael Ball performed his UK Number 2 chart-hit from “Aspects of Love” – Love Changes Everything’. It is a song that he has made his own and the audience gorged itself on the music of their chosen one.

So was Nicholas Kenyon right when he denied charges of “dumbing down” at the Proms this year? Kenyon knows an audience-puller when he sees one and ever since his predecessor John Drummond programmed Birtwistle’s Panic in the second half of the Last Night in 1995 (his last Prom as Controller) Kenyon has seen fit to challenge what are considered the established norms of the Festival. Where the Proms goes from here. Despite possibly correct criticism that this concert was better suited to Radio 2 than Radio 3 it was a success in terms of audience enjoyment rather than musical finesse.

An Evening with Michael Ball Read More »

The Water Diviner’s Tale

Rachel Portman/Owen Sheers
The Water Diviner’s Tale [BBC commission world premiere]

Water Diviner – Nonso Anozie (narrator)
Weather Girl – Frances Bourne (mezzo-soprano)

Ensemble:
Helen Williams (soprano)
Robert Burt (tenor)
Riccardo Simonetti (baritone)
Paul Reeves (bass)

Lost Children [chorus members selected by BBC New Talent]
Berkshire Maestros Youth Choir
Bromley Youth Choir
Members of Chantage
Hertfordshire County Youth Choir
Members of the National Youth Choir of Great Britain
Members of Taplow Youth Choir

BBC Concert Orchestra
David Charles Abell

Denni Sayers – Director
Anna Bruder – Designer


Reviewed by: Kenneth Carter

Reviewed: 27 August, 2007
Venue: Royal Albert Hall, London

This was a large spectacle, not without colour. The opening was a fairly robust musical storm with spotlights, high up on either side of the organ, shining simultaneously and intermittently. A boxing ring in the Arena was bare.

After the storm, ‘Lost Children’ poured down various aisles, gathering on this main platform, enlivening its muted green with a patchwork of multi-coloured tops. Adult attendants handed the children what looked like frozen mobiles – blue fishes on sticks and, later on, what may have been abstract symbols of fossil fuels. These adult attendants also gave voice to ‘adult’ views on gas, oil and coal consumption. The BBC Concert Orchestra sat in the usual place. Above were the massed ranks of some 40 young people in the choir stalls. Sitting by a gangway on the top row, in a bright yellow dress, was the Weather Girl. She expressed a bleak and extremely long-range forecast for decades to come.

In terms of spectacle, the star of the show was the narrator – the Water Diviner. His extravagant light-blue headgear was matched by a long light-blue gown. Carrying a very long, very dried-up twig, he appeared from behind the conductor and gravely descended to the Arena to lament the environmental catastrophe, his failure to divine water and querying whether life on our planet has a future.
The ‘Lost Children’ were homeless, water-less and nigh future-less due the apocalyptic storm, brought about through global warming and caused by adults’ misuse of our planet’s resources. The Water Diviner, after some spiritual journeying on his own account, gave them two insights: their collective voice is strong, even though their individual voices are weak; and children must open adults’ eyes to the ways of nature. A sober but viable future can be created. There is still time.

Rachel Portman’s previous dramatic/operatic work was “The Little Prince”. Saint-Exupery’s simple and piercing innocence will last as long as people use words. Poet and novelist Owen Sheers’s words, though noble and sincere, are not quite of this calibre. I found his script rather old-fashioned.

Portman’s music was more skilled: simply scored, but demanding; alert and adept. She has, after all, received an Oscar for her film music. Different moods were nicely judged and delineated and – whether from orchestra, youthful choirs or adult soloists – executed with resounding vigour and freshness.

Will the piece make ‘green’ converts? Maybe. It certainly had the sterling worth of engaging full musical commitment from its performers – and invoking their ‘green’ allegiance, too.

The Water Diviner’s Tale Read More »

Songs of a Rhineland Harper

Songs of the Harp:
Caute, cane, cantor care
Magnus cesar Otto
Rota modos arte
David regis inclita proles

The Harper in the Snake Pit:
Atli sendi ár til Gunnars

Desire and Seduction:
Advertite, omnes populi
Puella turbata
Suavissima nunna
Veni, dilectissime

Sequentia [Benjamin Bagby (director, voice, lyre & harp), Agnethe Christensen & Eric Mentzel (voices) & Norbert Rodenkirchen (flute & lyre)]


Reviewed by: Nick Breckenfield

Reviewed: 27 August, 2007
Venue: Cadogan Hall, London

I wonder if the Proms had ever hosted music as old as this, even in its Millennium of Music day back in 2000. Here we had a three-part programme given by Sequentia of works that around one-thousand years old, mostly from 11th-century Rhineland, but also including a central section from 10th-century Iceland (although also about the Rhine).

The outer sections were taken from a collection now in Cambridge that came from the Rhineland via Canterbury and which is now known as “Carmina Cantabrigiensia”, with various scholarly techniques to reconstruct possible melodies to the various texts within.

Sequentia is led from the lyre (or harp) by Benjamin Bagby, whose solo recitation of the first half of “Beowulf” self-accompanied on the Anglo-Saxon harp has to be seen and heard to be believed (and is now available on a Region 1 DVD). Here, with his three fellow Early Music exponents, Bagby started this lunchtime programme with a set of ‘praise songs’ all including direct references to harpers (I had always assumed that those that played the harp were ‘harpists’, but no, seemingly they are ‘harpers’!).

“Caute, cane, cantor care” (Sing circumspectly, sweet singer) – with Agnethe Christensen’s distinctive voice – urges to make your whole body an instrument, while “Magnus cesar Otto” praises three great emperor Ottos, the first of whom was notably saved from a fire by none-other-than-a harper! A Rhineland harper’s life as an itinerant educator was illustrated by “Rota modos arte” (Let us sound melodies loudly) which quotes Pythagoras, while that Biblical harper of note, David, was celebrated in “David regis inclita proles” (The famous progeny of King David).

The middle section turned to an Icelandic forbear of Wagner’s “Göttterdämmerung” (which concludes his ‘Ring’ cycle) and, at less than 15 minutes, it was intensely more dramatic, telling of brothers Gunnar and Hogni as they set out, leaving sister Gudrun, to battle with Atli. Captured (but not before Hogni has slayed eight of his enemies, seven by his sword, the other by being pushed into flames), Gunnar refuses to tell Atli where the Rhine-gold is until his brother’s heart is placed in his hand. First they try to trick him by cutting out coward slave Hialli’s heart, but Gunnar sees through the trick, so Hogni is also killed. Then Gunnar is thrown into a pit of snakes, where he shows his utter disdain for Atli and his punishment by playing the harp! It was left to Gudrun to avenge her brothers…

Here, seated with harp on his left thigh, Bagby revisited the heroic style of tale-telling I recognised from his “Beowulf” rendition, dramatic gesturing melding with his rich baritone speaking (and sometimes intoning) voice. Here he had the luxury of hand-held drum and a flute to help the telling (one of the advantages of having fellow-performers), as well as Agnethe Christensen’s taking of Gudrun’s lines. One could easily understand why such roving performers were both important and lauded a thousand years ago, with such bloody tales of derring-do.

The last section was more sensual; also including was a purely instrumental piece entitled ‘Girl Perturbed’, about a girl who, out of wedlock, is pregnant. Of the three songs, “Advertite, omnes populi” tells of an errant wife, who had sired a child by another while her merchant husband was shipwrecked. On his return she claimed she had been made pregnant by snow, but the husband – eventually – turns the tables on her. He takes the now eight-year-old boy on a trading trip and sells him as a slave, returning to tell his wife that, shipwrecked on a sandy shore, the boy had melted in the sun…

A nun’s attempt to not be tempted was the subject of the penultimate song, “Suavissima nunna”, while the final song – “Veni, dilectissime” – with its ‘oohing’ and ‘aahing’, needed little extra-musical elaboration.

In essence, this was like the original medieval version of “Carmina Burana”, so memorably refashioned in orchestral and choral style by Carl Orff (to stunning effect). While much of the music sounded very similar, the intrigue of the texts and the very fact – even in renditions that have to rely on guess-work as much as scholarship – that this is music sounding again after one-thousand years, made this a most unusual, and successful, Proms Chamber Music recital.

Songs of a Rhineland Harper Read More »