The Royal Opera – Carmen [Antonacci & Kaufmann]

Bizet
Carmen – Opéra comique in four acts; libretto by Henry Meilhac and Ludovic Halévy after Prosper Mérimée’s novel [Sung in French with English surtitles]

Moralès – Jaques Imbrailo
Micaëla – Norah Amsellem
Don José – Jonas Kaufmann
Zuniga – Matthew Rose
Carmen – Anna Caterina Antonacci
Frasquita – Elena Xanthoudakis
Mercédès – Viktoria Vizin
Lillas Pastia – Caroline Lena Olsson
Escamillo – Ildebrando D’Arcangelo
Le Dancaïre – Jean Sébastien Bou
Le Remendado – Jean-Paul Fouchécourt
Guide – Anthony Debaeck

The Royal Opera Chorus
The Orchestra of the Royal Opera House
Antonio Pappano

Francesca Zambello – Director
Tanya McCallin – Designs
Paule Constable – Lighting
Arthur Pita – Choreography


Reviewed by: Alexander Campbell

Reviewed: 11 December, 2006
Venue: The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, London

This was the second performance of the Royal Opera’s new production of “Carmen”, a co-production with Norwegian National Opera (Den Norske Opera), which will open a new opera house in April 2008. Covent Garden is obviously banking on this production being a success as it has a long run over this festive period. At this performance the production only took fire in the final scene; the earlier acts certainly had their moments but were not always sustaining of the drama.

The current cast of the production has one absolute ace up its sleeve in the form of the Bavarian tenor Jonas Kaufmann, who gives as complete a performance as Don José as one could ever expect to hear. From the start not only was the role superbly and subtly vocalised, but also the character’s gradual decline was depicted not only in some great and natural acting but also in the vocal character as well. Don José’s emotional aspect of the character registered immediately and as the evening went on, increasing frustration and desperation crept into the tone, matching his increasingly shabby and shaggy demeanour. Kaufmann is not a tenor for histrionic effects, however; the ‘Flower Song’ was beautifully lyrical, ending on a true pianissimo, and his ringing tones in the final duet were thrilling as well as upsetting.

Here, Anna Caterina Antonacci finally made one focus on and realise Carmen’s tragedy, suddenly defiant and desperately longing for life in a situation she knows is probably hopeless. She also seemed vocally happier at this point and revealed herself the operatic actress she is known to be. Earlier she seemed content merely to express the somewhat clichéd aspects of the character – an earthy, liberated, and vulgar gypsy, although unusually, this Carmen seemed to retain some feeling for Don José well into the third act. Vocally Antonacci was secure, although her rather soprano-ish timbre meant that she was almost out-mezzo’d by the slightly richer voice of Viktoria Vizin’s Mercédès, when they were singing together. Antonacci does has a luscious and alluring middle range which sits well in most of the part, but what it lacks perhaps is penetrative power. Whilst not perhaps such an all-round performance as Kaufmann’s she is a worthy partner to him.

Ildebrando D’Arcangelo’s Escamillo was a strong presence, firmly sung, and acted with the necessary swagger, even whilst making his first entrance atop a large black horse (unusual to bring your horse inside a tavern?). The Micaëla of Norah Amsellem was disappointing. She acted the role well enough within the confines of the production, but her voice lacks the richness that the singer of the part needs in order to provide a vocal and dramatic foil to Carmen. Ansellem’s voice is always somewhat tremulous, and not always mellifluous in tone quality.

In the minor roles the bright and optimistic Frasquita of Elena Xanthoudakis, and Matthew Rose’s Zuniga stood out, and it was a pleasure to see and hear the inimitable Jean-Paul Fouchécourt turning in a cameo as a crafty Le Remendado.

On the musical side things were also mixed. Pappano and his orchestra launched into the famous opening with a gusto that only just missed being labelled coarse, but elsewhere there was some fine playing, especially in the famous interludes, and real swagger in the crowd scenes that open the final act. Mention should be made of the excellent flute-playing in the Act Three Prelude. The score played was not the most authentic with some of the Guiraud-composed accompanied recitative creeping in on occasion. That the conductor allowed his director to obliterate most of the lovely orchestration of the dance that opens Act Two by some rather noisy dancing and chorus whoops seemed odd, and Escamillo’s off-stage singing at the end of the third act was far too close for someone who should be rather more distantly heard. Surely the conductor should have said something and these miscalculations been addressed?

Francesca Zambello’s production was mounted in Tanya McCallin’s elegant rather simple and abstract designs, which are beautifully lit; the solid scenery subtly invoking the settings of both internal and external scenes – especially the mountain pass of Act Three. It thus seemed a bit perverse to populate these settings with unnecessary and distracting realism of such as live donkeys, horses and chickens and the like, and also to have many of the smugglers, including Don José, abseiling down the scenery. It seemed that the concentration was on directing superfluous detail at the expense of the principals – Kaufmann excepted. Zambello’s previous flair for chorus direction seems to have deserted her also. At times movement looked almost formulaic – though it must be said the choral singers were on fine vocal form. One wondered also why Lillas Pastia, who is usually a male character (and one therefore assumes that historically it has always been so), should have changed sex.

These may be minor irritations to the regular opera-goer – as a production this will easily harbour many and varied casts and will prove an attractive and straightforward presentation for those seeing the work for the first time.



  • The first night was 8 December
  • Remaining performances on 15, 19, 22, 28 & 30 December, and on 2 & 6 January – all conducted by Pappano – and 8 January (conducted by David Syrus); and – with a change of cast, Philippe Augin conducting – on 22, 24, 26 & 31 January, and 3 February. All performances are at 7.00 except 6 January and 3 February, which begin at 6.30
  • Broadcast on BBC Radio 3 on 26 December at 7.30
  • Box office: 020 7304 4000
  • Royal Opera

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share This
Skip to content